Skip to main content

MERP: Further Thoughts on MERP


I continue to find MERP enjoyable to run, and quite a bit more playable than its reputation would lead one to believe. There is no doubt in my mind that the combination of the tools available through Roll20, and Scott's super-helpful scripts, increase the fun factor of this game quite a bit. The increased speed of play gained by eliminating the table searching allows the tactical detail introduced by those tables to really shine through, adding a layer of surprise to combat that other systems lack. On several occasions, the players have been forced to alter their tactics in a fight because of a result on the critical tables either going for or against them. The layer of detailed added by the adjustments to Defensive Bonuses based on positioning and stun also add to the tactical element. Even a multi-session combat (as we will see in The Battle of the Barrow Downs) can stay interesting and exciting to run, something I have never experienced in a D&D descended game.

 I am also enjoying the looser class definitions that RoleMaster/MERP bring to the table. Dirdan is able to participate in the full scope of the fellowship's activities in addition to contributing through his limited spells. Even the warriors can have a spell or two. Dirdan's invisibility spell has allowed him to basically become the party scout, a role far too dangerous for a standard D&D Magic User.

Many of the ICE books are great for background material, but they suffer from two problems:

  1. They rarely present "ready to run" game material, no matter what it says on the cover. For the most part, the adventures in these books are really just outlines that need significant work on the part of the GM to get going. This isn't really a problem for me, I tend to heavily rework premade adventures no matter what, but it is important to note that you cannot rely on them if you find yourself in a preparation bind. Also, the adventure outlines are nowhere as inspired as the setting information. I actually prefer the adventures made for The One Ring/Adventures in Middle Earth.
  2. The Middle Earth Bestiary is starting to be a problem for me. There just aren't all that many different monsters baked into the setting. Worse, due to years of fantasy RPGs riffing of LotR, most of the monsters are ones that the players have seen hundreds of times over. This has put me in the interesting position of trying to use as few monsters as possible when planning my games, relying on human foes more often than not. Despite that, the fellowship has already faced two trolls, several wights, and orcs. I have been trying to hold orcs and goblins in reserve as much as possible. The vaious underwater creatures and the from demons in the Tharbad sewer adventures are present in the MERP materials, but I suspect they come from the MERP designers facing the same problem I am. Honestly, even with their additions to the actual Tolkien monsters, the MERP bestiary is still very limited, consisting mostly of birds and fish. The appeal of this game is adventuring in Middle Earth and the tactical depth, and those two are starting to be in tension with one another due to the lack of monster types. I may have to just start adding monsters from other sources that seem appropriate.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Hex Crawls

Those of you who have been reading this blog know that I have never run a megadungeon before. I have always used more realistic dungeon settings, keeping all underground areas to a minimum and keeping the over all size of castles and the like fairly small. There is another style of gaming I have never indulged in: the hex crawl. I have never seen hexes as discrete chunks of the map. I always just used them as a guide to find distance if they were present and not worrying about themif they were not. I have always taken a more continuous view of overland maps. This is another streak that will be ending with my upcoming OSRIC game. I will be using James M's Outdoor Map as a starting pont in my campaign. I will be heavily modifying it for my purposes but most of the features will stay the same. I will be adding my own versions of Castles Blackmoor and Greyhawk to the map. I have been struggling with how a hex crawl works. How do I know if they find features in the hex and isn't 5 m

Traveller: Session 5

    This is part of an ongoing campaign. You can find the other sessions over on the sidebar. This session was run on October 27, 2022. This session contains secret communications between me and the individual players. This means that these recaps do not cover everything that happened in the session. I will be reporting only the information that all players had access to.   131-1116   After the council meeting ended, Nashu, Archduke Ishuggi’s chief of staff, pulled him aside. Following the revelation that Yuri Lang, the emperor’s would-be assassin, had been a member of Archduke Adair’s intelligence service and had been involved in a combined operation with Gateway Intelligence, she had the staff run overlap checks on all recent contacts. The goal was to determine if there were any more unexpected connections between people that could be a threat to Ishuggi or the emperor.   She learned that, in 1113, Yuri Lang (“Baron Pazi”), Zurzi (Archduke Bzrk’s chief of st

Traveller: Session 24

    This session was run on March 30, 2023.     With the Prismatic Ray safely on the ground and camouflaged, Aryanna decided to head to the artists’ commune to monitor the situation with the pirates they had escaped from and to establish radio contact with Arenui and Mar-ven through local channels to avoid giving away their position. Mhan, Hal, and Zarf stayed behind with the ship. Using the Ray’s passive sensors, they could see that the Razer’s Blade , the 100 ton boat launched from Jugisaal’s Razer to intercept them, had finished with Jade’s cargo lighter and was entering Twinsong’s atmosphere. In Caldera, Arenui and Mar-ven were finishing up negotiations at the life support supply warehouse when the air defense alert sirens started to sound. The warehouse owner told them that they had to leave the building while he took his employees into the strong room. They attempted to convince him to allow them to shelter in the strong room as well, but he refused becau